When you walk into a library, you might notice that books on the same topic are scattered across different sections. A book on fashion design sits near art, while a book on the psychology of dress is tucked away in the psychology section. This isn’t a mistake-it’s a deliberate choice rooted in how library classification systems organize knowledge. At the heart of this organization lie two fundamental concepts: discipline and main class. Understanding these concepts helps us see why different classification systems approach knowledge organization so differently, and how the choice between discipline-based and faceted systems shapes what we find on library shelves.
Table of Contents
What exactly is a discipline?
A discipline is not simply a topic or subject. Instead, a discipline represents a fundamental area of knowledge defined by its own research methodology, theoretical frameworks, and scholarly community. Think of it as a field of academic study with established ways of investigating problems. Physics is a discipline, economics is a discipline, and literature is a discipline. Each has its own tools, questions, and ways of seeking answers.
The key difference between a discipline and a topic lies in methodology. For example, “health” could be studied from multiple disciplinary perspectives-medicine approaches it through biological research, sociology examines it through social patterns, and psychology explores it through mental well-being. Each discipline brings its own lens. A discipline, then, is not the subject itself, but the organized way of studying that subject through a particular field’s unique perspective and methods.
This distinction becomes crucial when librarians decide how to arrange materials. Should they organize books by what they’re about, or by the discipline that created them? This question has shaped entire classification systems.
Understanding the concept of main class
A main class is the broadest division within a classification system, representing a major discipline or area of knowledge. Main classes form the foundation of any library classification scheme. Every book in the library eventually gets assigned to one of these broad categories, which then branches into narrower subdivisions.
The main class acts as the first level of organization-the point where the entire universe of knowledge is divided into manageable chunks. How many main classes should exist? How should they be ordered? What should each one contain? These questions don’t have obvious answers. Different library pioneers answered them differently, which is why we have multiple classification systems today, each with its own set of main classes organized according to different principles.
Think of main classes as the primary organizational architecture of a library. The number and scope of these classes determine everything that follows-how specific you can get with subdivisions, how easy it is to find related materials, and how well the system accommodates new knowledge as it emerges.
The Dewey Decimal Classification and its approach
The Dewey Decimal Classification (DDC) organizes knowledge into ten main classes, each represented by the digits 000 through 900. These ten classes cover the entire world of knowledge, from general works to history and geography. The elegance of this system lies in its simplicity: ten broad categories, each subdivided into ten divisions, creating an expandable structure using decimal notation.
What makes DDC distinctive is its discipline-based approach. The DDC is “arranged by discipline, not subject”, meaning that materials are classified according to the discipline studying them, not the topic itself. Consider clothing again: a book on the psychological influence of dress gets classified under psychology (155.95), while a book on fashion design goes under arts (746.92), and a book on clothing customs appears under social sciences (391). The same subject-clothing-exists in three different places because it’s being studied through three different disciplinary lenses.
The inspiration for DDC’s structure came from an unexpected source: English philosopher Francis Bacon and his theory of knowledge based on the three mental faculties of memory, imagination, and reason. Melvil Dewey, the system’s creator, adapted Bacon’s framework, organizing knowledge around these fundamental human capacities. This philosophical foundation gave DDC a coherent structure, though modern scholars have questioned whether Bacon’s theory of three mental faculties remains scientifically valid.
The ten main classes in DDC are:
000-099 Computer science, information, and general works 100-199 Philosophy and psychology 200-299 Religion 300-399 Social sciences 400-499 Languages 500-599 Science 600-699 Technology 700-799 Arts and recreation 800-899 Literature 900-999 History and geography
Each main class divides into ten divisions, and each division divides into ten sections, allowing for increasing specificity. The first digit represents the main class, the second digit represents the division, and the third represents the section, with decimals allowing further subdivision.
The Colon Classification and its faceted approach
In contrast, the Colon Classification (CC), developed by S. R. Ranganathan, was the first truly faceted classification system and was first published in 1933. Rather than limiting knowledge to ten main classes, CC contains 42 main classes in its initial structure, expanding to 108 main classes in later editions.
The philosophical difference is profound. While DDC assumes that knowledge naturally falls into ten broad disciplines, CC operates on the principle that a single item can simultaneously belong to multiple categories. Instead of forcing subjects into disciplinary slots, CC breaks down each class into facets-independent dimensions of meaning that can be combined. These facets are personality, matter, energy, space, and time (abbreviated as PMEST).
To illustrate: A book about tuberculosis treatment using X-rays in India in 1950 would, in CC, combine elements from different facets-the disease (personality), the treatment method (energy), the location (space), and the date (time). CC uses mixed notation including Arabic numerals, Roman letters, and Greek letters, with colons and other punctuation marks separating the facets. This complexity allows for incredibly precise specification but requires more training to use effectively.
The structural difference reflects a deeper philosophical disagreement. Ranganathan argued that hierarchical classification schemes like DDC are too limiting and finite for modern classification, since many items pertain to information across multiple subjects. Rather than accept discipline as the organizing principle, CC asks: What are the fundamental dimensions along which any subject can vary? The answer-personality, matter, energy, space, and time-applies universally.
Why the differences matter
The variation in main classes between DDC and CC isn’t merely academic. These differences produce real consequences for how knowledge is organized and retrieved. With only ten main classes, DDC requires long call numbers to reach specificity. A book on nuclear physics becomes 539.7, requiring many digits. With more main classes, CC can be more granular at the top level.
The discipline-based approach of DDC works well when subjects map neatly onto established academic disciplines. But it struggles with interdisciplinary topics. Environmental science, for instance, draws from biology, chemistry, geology, and social sciences-yet in DDC, it must live primarily in one class. Contemporary interdisciplinary subjects do not fit neatly into a single discipline, making it difficult to classify them under one Dewey number.
The faceted approach of CC handles such interdisciplinary work more flexibly by allowing multiple dimensions to be expressed simultaneously. However, this flexibility comes with a cost: the notation becomes more complex, and librarians need more expertise to classify materials correctly.
Which approach wins?
There is no universal “better” system. DDC remains the most widely used classification system in the world and is commonly found in public libraries. Its simplicity and standardization make it attractive for general libraries serving diverse patrons. CC, meanwhile, is especially used in libraries in India and remains popular among academic librarians who appreciate its precision.
Each system represents a choice about what matters most: discipline-based organization that matches academic structures, or faceted organization that permits greater specificity and flexibility. Understanding these choices helps library users and information professionals appreciate why knowledge is organized the way it is, and how different approaches can serve different needs.
What do you think? In your own research or reading, have you noticed how the same subject appears in different parts of a library? Does organizing materials by discipline, as DDC does, feel intuitive, or would you prefer a system that captures multiple dimensions of a topic simultaneously?
References
- https://www.oclc.org/content/dam/oclc/dewey/resources/summaries/deweysummaries.pdf
- https://www.librarianshipstudies.com/2026/01/dewey-decimal-classification-ddc.html
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/social-sciences/library-classification
- https://egyankosh.ac.in/bitstream/123456789/35741/5/Unit-4.pdf
- https://libguides.wcsu.edu/c.php?g=119515&p=780043
- https://en-academic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/3891
- https://limbd.org/facet-classification-scheme/
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/computer-science/colon-classification
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faceted_classification
- https://www.lisedunetwork.com/dewey-decimal-classification-23rd-edition/

Leave a Reply