Walk into any two libraries and you may find the same book shelved in completely different places. A title on the history of medicine might sit under history in one collection and under medical science in another. This is not a mistake. It reveals something fundamental about how we organise knowledge: classification is never fixed, never neutral, and never the only correct option. Every system of arranging information is a human decision shaped by purpose, culture, and the needs of a particular time. Understanding this changing and relative nature of classification is the first step towards using these systems wisely rather than treating them as unquestionable rules.
Table of Contents
- Classification as a relative concept
- Why no system is final
- Man-made classifications and their purposes
- Purpose decides the categories
- Examples across time
- The Vedic classification of knowledge
- Aristotle’s classification of the sciences
- The adaptability of classification
- When old categories no longer fit
- From print shelves to digital data
- Why this matters for organising information
Classification as a relative concept
There is no single, absolute, universally correct way to classify knowledge. A classification scheme always depends on the context in which it is built and used. The same item can belong to different categories depending on who is doing the organising and why. A book on water management could be classed under engineering, environmental science, agriculture, or public policy, and each choice would be defensible.
This relativity exists because library classification aims at a useful ordering of documents rather than a perfect theoretical map of knowledge. The goal is practical usefulness, not philosophical truth. A medical college library will arrange its collection very differently from a school library, even when both hold some of the same books, because their users approach the material with different questions and different needs.
Why no system is final
Because classification serves human purposes, it can never be complete or permanent. Knowledge keeps growing, disciplines keep merging, and yesterday’s neat categories start to feel cramped. A subject considered minor a century ago may now demand an entire section of its own. A field that did not exist when a scheme was first written has to be squeezed into whatever space is available. This is why every major classification system is revised again and again rather than finished once and left alone.
Man-made classifications and their purposes
Every classification system is a human-made construct designed to meet a specific need. Nobody discovered the categories of a library scheme lying ready in nature. People invented them. Once we accept this, the variety of systems around us makes perfect sense, because different purposes naturally lead to different ways of dividing the same body of knowledge.
Consider how differently information is grouped depending on the aim. A bookshop arranges titles to encourage browsing and buying, so it leans on broad, appealing categories like self-help, fiction, and competitive exams. A research database arranges the same material by precise subject descriptors so scholars can retrieve narrow topics quickly. A bookseller’s “popular science” shelf and a university catalogue’s detailed subject headings are organising similar content for entirely different audiences.
Purpose decides the categories
The purpose behind a system quietly decides what it treats as important. A classification built for a law library will create fine distinctions within legal subjects while collapsing everything about cooking into a single heading. A culinary institute would do the exact opposite. Neither is wrong. Each emphasises what matters to its community and ignores what does not. This is also why two systems can both be excellent yet completely incompatible, because they were never trying to answer the same question in the first place.
Examples across time
History gives us some of the clearest proof that classification reflects the worldview of its makers. Two ancient traditions, one Indian and one Greek, organised the whole of knowledge in strikingly different ways, and each tells us about the society that produced it.
The Vedic classification of knowledge
In the Indian tradition, knowledge was famously divided into two broad kinds. The higher knowledge, or para vidya, dealt with the realisation of ultimate reality, while the lower knowledge, or apara vidya, covered the textual and worldly subjects. As this distinction explains, the lower knowledge included the four Vedas along with subjects like pronunciation, ritual, grammar, etymology, metre, and astronomy. The defining line between the two categories was spiritual purpose, not subject matter alone.
Within this framework, worldly learning was further organised into the vidyasthanas, the recognised abodes of knowledge. The Yajnavalkya Smriti refers to fourteen such sources of knowledge, including the four Vedas, the six Vedangas, and disciplines such as Purana, Nyaya, Mimamsa, and Dharmashastra. When four more branches such as Ayurveda, Dhanurveda, Gandharvaveda, and Arthashastra are added, the count rises to eighteen vidyasthanas. What stands out here is the organising principle: knowledge was grouped according to its relationship with dharma and spiritual goals, placing liberation at the very top of the hierarchy.
Aristotle’s classification of the sciences
In ancient Greece, Aristotle approached the same task with an entirely different logic. He divided all knowledge into three categories based on the purpose each kind of inquiry served. As this overview describes, the purpose of theoretical knowledge is the pursuit of truth through contemplation, the purpose of productive knowledge is making something, and the purpose of practical knowledge is wise action in ethical and political life.
Under this scheme, theoretical sciences like mathematics, physics, and metaphysics aimed at understanding reality for its own sake. Practical sciences like ethics and politics aimed at guiding human conduct. Productive sciences like medicine and craft aimed at creating useful or beautiful objects. The key point is that Aristotle’s dividing line was the telos, or goal, of each activity. Where the Vedic tradition organised knowledge around its spiritual end, Aristotle organised it around the type of human aim involved.
Placed side by side, these two systems show that even the deepest thinkers of their civilisations did not converge on one natural order of knowledge. Each sorted the world according to what their culture valued most. That alone settles the question of whether any classification can be absolute.
The adaptability of classification
If classification reflects the needs of a society, then it must change as those needs change. Adaptability is not a weakness of these systems; it is the very reason they remain useful. A scheme that cannot evolve quickly becomes a museum piece.
The modern library schemes make this obvious. The Dewey Decimal Classification, invented by Melvil Dewey in 1873 and published in 1876, has been continually revised to keep pace with new knowledge and is now used in over a hundred countries. When it was first created, fields such as computer science and genetic engineering simply did not exist. The system had to stretch and reorganise itself repeatedly to make room for subjects its creator could never have imagined.
When old categories no longer fit
Adaptation is not only about adding new subjects. It is also about correcting categories that no longer serve users well. Because every system carries the assumptions of its makers, older schemes often reflect outdated or unbalanced worldviews. Critics have long pointed out that the Dewey system shows a Western-centric design, for example by giving far more space to Christianity than to other religions, although revisions have addressed some of these issues. Recognising such bias is part of why ongoing revision matters, especially for diverse and multi-religious societies.
From print shelves to digital data
The biggest test of adaptability has come with the shift from print to digital. Traditional schemes were built to place a physical book in one fixed spot on a shelf. Digital resources do not sit on shelves at all, and a single item may need to be findable under many headings at once. This pushed the field towards more flexible, faceted, and metadata-based approaches that let one resource carry multiple labels for title, creator, and subject. The underlying lesson is consistent: as the form of information changes, the methods of organising it must follow, or they stop being useful.
Why this matters for organising information
Seeing classification as relative and changeable is not a reason to distrust it. It is a reason to use it thoughtfully. When you understand that a system is a human tool built for a purpose, you stop asking whether a book is in the “right” place and start asking whether the arrangement serves its users. You also become alert to the gaps and biases that every scheme carries, which makes you a sharper organiser and a more critical user of information.
For anyone working with knowledge, whether in a library, a database, or a digital archive, the takeaway is simple. Choose or adapt a classification that fits your purpose, your users, and your time, and stay ready to revise it as those things change. No system will be perfect, but a well-chosen and well-maintained one will always be useful.
What do you think? If classification always reflects the values of its makers, how would you redesign a knowledge system to better represent the subjects and communities that older schemes overlooked? And as more of our information becomes digital, do you think fixed categories will survive, or will flexible tagging eventually replace them entirely?
References
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_classification
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Para_Vidya
- https://vedicheritage.gov.in/introduction/
- https://ebooks.inflibnet.ac.in/icp05/chapter/chapter-1/
- https://infed.org/dir/welcome/aristotle-on-knowledge/
- https://isbndb.com/blog/dewey-decimal-system/
- https://www.librarianshipstudies.com/2026/01/dewey-decimal-classification-ddc.html

Leave a Reply